Something hand made if you are an artist. My last girl friend was a pretty good gift giver, just never seemed to get it right until my last birthday. She would always try and out do herself trying to get my expensive things.
My favorite gift she ever got me was a drawing of my name, with a lot of my hobbies in the picture. I know that thing took her hours to draw, and the entire time she was thinking about me. Thats what made me feel special.