Trans people of Reddit who have gone HRT earlier in life, what was your experience? do you think it is ethical for someone underaged to go through such a procedure?

Not trans, but for what it’s worth, underage kids almost never do go on hormone replacement unless it’s medically necessary (which often happens to kids who aren’t even trans). Trans people usually take meds that delay puberty until they’re older, which are much more reversible.

None of this is particularly bad unless you assume the kid just has absolutely no agency of their own